| 2007 |
| Dr. Noah Allen -
Euchee/Creek -
Coaching and Athletic Administration |
| William "Bill" Bredde -
Quechan/Pawnee -
Football |
| Pete Shepherd -
Santee Sioux -
Football |
| Edward "Eddie" Burgess -
Creek/Cherokee -
Rodeo |
| |
| 2006 |
| Stephen Gachupin -
Walatowa Pueblo of Jemez -
Marathon, Distance Runner |
| Emmitt Peters -
Athabascan -
Dog Musher |
| Aloysuis "Al" Waqui -
Walatowa Pueblo of Jemez -
Cross Country, Distance Runner |
| |
| 2004 |
| Howard Gayle Hatch -
Delaware -
Weightlifting Coach, Basketball |
| Larry Joe Ramirez -
Pascua Yaqui/Chirrirchua Apache -
Baseball |
| Jim E. Warne, Jr -
Oglala Lakota Sioux -
Football |
| |
| 2000 |
| R. Perry Beaver -
Creek -
Football |
| Robert J. Cannon -
Osage -
Track |
| Andrew Sockalexis -
Penobscot -
Marathon Runner |
| Louis F. Sockalexis -
Penobscot -
Baseball |
| |
| 1997 |
| James L. Johnson -
Menominee -
Football |
| Jimmie Earl Keel -
Chickasaw -
Boxing |
| Mike Edwards -
Cherokee/Choctaw/Chickasaw -
Bowling |
| |
| 1996 |
| Ryneldi Becenti -
Navajo -
Basketball |
| George BlueSpruce -
Laguna/San Juan -
Tennis |
| John Seller -
Cherokee -
Baseball |
| |
| 1995 |
| Dawn Kelly Allen -
Euchee/Quapaw/Cherokee -
Tennis |
| Karen Mackey -
Santee Sioux -
Judo |
| Thomas Stidham -
Creek -
Football |
| |
| 1994 |
| Moses Yellow Horse -
Pawnee -
Baseball |
| Jackson Sundown -
Nex Perce -
Rodeo |
| Sammy Jack Claphan -
Cherokee -
Football |
| |
| 1991 |
| John "Johnny" Allen -
Tonkawa/Sac & Fox -
Football |
| Edwin "Ed" Moore -
Creek -
Football |
| Andrew "Andy" Payne -
Cherokee -
Cross Country/Football |
| |
| 1989 |
| Clarence "Taffy" Abel -
Chippewa -
Hockey |
| James Aron Ingram -
Cherokee -
Baseball |
| Eual "Monk" Moore -
Chickasaw -
Baseball |
| Alvin L. Williams -
Caddo -
Boxing |
| |
| 1987 |
| Peter Hauser -
Cheyenne -
Football |
| Mayes McLain -
Cherokee -
Football |
| Arthur S. Bensell -
Mackanutunne/Siletz -
Football |
| Alex "Sonny" Sixkiller -
Cherokee -
Football |
| Wallace "Wally" Galluzzi -
Honorary -
|
| |
| 1985 |
| Sampson "Sam" Bird -
Blackfeet -
Football |
| Virgil R. Franklin -
Arapaho/Kiowa -
Boxing |
| Robert "Bobby" Holmes -
Ottawa -
Football/Track and Field |
| Gordon A. House -
Navajo/Oneida -
Boxing |
| Sid Carney -
Creek/Choctaw -
Honorary |
| |
| 1982 |
| Amos Aitson -
Kiowa -
Football/Boxing |
| George Levi -
Arapaho -
Football |
| Thomas "Wahoo" Yarr -
Snohomish -
Football |
| Turner A. Cochran -
Caddo/Chickasaw -
Honorary |
| |
| 1981 |
| David W. Bray -
Seneca -
Lacross/Track |
| Nelson B. Levering -
Omaha/Bannock -
Boxing |
| Austin B. Tincup -
Cherokee -
Baseball |
| George P. Lavatta -
Shoshone/Bannock -
Honorary |
| |
| 1980 |
| Robert Gawboy -
Chippewa -
Swimming |
| Elijah "Eli" Smith -
Oneida -
Football/Baseball/Track |
| Martin F. Wheelock -
Oneida -
Football |
| |
| 1978 |
| Harold "Chuck" Foster -
Navajo -
Track/Cross Country |
| William "Billy" Mills -
Sioux -
10K Olympic Champion |
| Dr. Joseph "Bud" Sahmaunt -
Kiowa -
Basketball |
| Joe Tindell Thornton -
Cherokee -
Archery |
| Egbert "Eg" Ward -
Yakima -
Football/Baseball/Basketball |
| Frank W. McDonald -
Honorary -
|
| |
| 1977 |
| Chester "Chet" Ellis -
Seneca -
Boxing |
| Stacy S. Howell -
Pawnee -
Basketball |
| Jack Jacobs -
Creek -
Football |
| Clyde "Chief" James -
Modoc -
Basketball |
| Rollie Munsell Jr. -
Chickasaw -
Boxing |
| Phillip Osif -
Pima -
Track/Cross Country |
| Robert L. Bennett -
Oneida -
Honorary |
| |
| 1973 |
| Ellison Brown -
Narrangasett -
Marathon |
| Wallace Little Finger -
Sioux -
Track/Field |
| Elmer Busch -
Pomo -
Football |
| Albert Hawley -
Gros Ventre/Assiniboin -
Football |
| Frank Hudson -
Laguna -
Football |
| Frank Mt. Pleasant -
Tuscarora -
Football |
| Walter Johnson -
Paiute -
Football |
| Jessie Renich -
Choctaw -
Basketball |
| Gus Welch -
Chippewa -
Football |
| Jimmie Wolfe Jr. -
Kiowa -
Football |
| Angelita Rosel -
Sioux -
Table Tennis |
| Bemus Pierce -
Seneca -
Football |
| Ed Rogers -
Chippewa -
Football |
| Louis R. Bruce -
Mohawk/Sioux -
Honorary |
| |
| 1972 |
| Alexander Arcasa -
Colville -
Football |
| Charles "Chief" Bender -
Chippewa -
Baseball |
| Wilson "Buster" Charles -
Oneida -
Olympic Decathlon |
| Albert A. Exendine -
Delaware -
Football |
| Joseph N. Guyon -
Chippewa -
Football |
| Jimmie Johnson -
Stockbridge/Munsee -
Football |
| John Levi -
Arapaho -
Football |
| John "Chief" Myers -
Cahuilla -
Baseball |
| Allie P. Reynolds -
Creek -
Baseball |
| Theodore "Tiny" Roebuck -
Choctaw -
Football |
| Reuben Sanders -
Tutuni/Rogue River -
Football |
| Louis Tewanima -
Hopi -
Track and Field |
| Jim Thorpe -
Sac and Fox -
Football/Baseball/Track |
| Louis "Rabbit" Weller -
Caddo -
Football |
