2004 |
Larry Joe Ramirez -
Pascua Yaqui/Chirrirchua Apache -
Baseball |
  |
2000 |
Louis F. Sockalexis -
Penobscot -
Baseball |
  |
1996 |
John Seller -
Cherokee -
Baseball |
  |
1994 |
Moses Yellow Horse -
Pawnee -
Baseball |
  |
1989 |
James Aron Ingram -
Cherokee -
Baseball |
Eual "Monk" Moore -
Chickasaw -
Baseball |
  |
1981 |
Austin B. Tincup -
Cherokee -
Baseball |
  |
1980 |
Elijah "Eli" Smith -
Oneida -
Football/Baseball/Track |
  |
1978 |
Egbert "Eg" Ward -
Yakima -
Football/Baseball/Basketball |
  |
1972 |
Charles "Chief" Bender -
Chippewa -
Baseball |
John "Chief" Myers -
Cahuilla -
Baseball |
Allie P. Reynolds -
Creek -
Baseball |
Jim Thorpe -
Sac and Fox -
Football/Baseball/Track |